Holds, copies, and why a second card still makes you wait

Last updated

A second Libby card borrows that library's copies, not a private pile. Here is what a hold is, what a second card changes, and what it cannot promise.

A hand pulling a single book from a library shelf.
Stock photograph of a library or of books. It is not a picture of a specific library in this directory.

The sales pitch for a second library card is that you will not wait. The pitch is half true, and the false half is the part that makes people feel cheated. A second card lets you borrow from a second set of licenses. It does not give you a private copy of every new book. If that library bought one copy and forty people are ahead of you, you are forty-first there too. You might be first at your home library and eightieth at the fancy one, or the other way around. You only learn which by searching after the card works.

What a copy is

Publishers license e-books to libraries under rules that look nothing like the paperback you buy. A library often pays more than a consumer pays, and the license expires after a period of time or a number of checkouts. Cincinnati's public comments about digital costs, and the library's own decision to end a free reciprocal deal, sit on that fact. You do not need the exact wholesale price to understand the line. The library does not own an infinite file. It owns the right to lend a certain number of copies.

Libby enforces that. One copy, one reader. Fairfax's guide says you borrow from Libby, loans return themselves, and you can have 10 items out. Brooklyn's Welcome Card FAQ, for people who actually qualify for that card, says 20 e-books or audiobooks and 10 holds. Those numbers are checkout limits, not a promise that 20 copies of one title exist. You can be allowed to borrow 10 items and still be unable to borrow the one item you want.

When the copies are all checked out, the button changes from borrow to place a hold. You wait. When a copy comes back, the next hold gets it for the loan period that library set, often 7, 14, or 21 days. Then it comes back again, unless you return it early. Returning early is the polite move and the one that makes the next person's wait shorter. It does not generate a new license. It frees the one the library already paid for.

What a second card changes

If your home library has 2 copies and 90 holds, and the second library has 2 copies and 4 holds, the second card is the one that will deliver the book sooner. That arithmetic is the entire point of paying. It is also invisible until you search. No page on this site prints those queues, because they move by the hour and the libraries did not publish a standing number we could cite.

The second card does nothing for a title the second library did not buy. A deep catalog in mystery is not a deep catalog in a textbook or a brand-new celebrity memoir. Queens can be a good second card for one reader and a useless one for another. You find out by searching your own list, not by reading a genre blurb on a roundup.

The second card also does nothing if it is barred from Libby. Fresno will issue a non-resident card and the table will still say Libby is off. You will not be in a Fresno Libby line. You will be in cloudLibrary, if you install that app, or you will be nowhere. Monroe County will put you in the Libby line and keep you out of Hoopla and Kanopy. The line you join is the vendor the library allowed.

Holds are not transferable

A hold at your home library stays there when you add Queens. Libby does not merge the queues. If you suspend a hold, you suspend it at that library. If you cancel it, the next person at that library moves up. Canceling a hold at a library you are about to drop, because the card expired, is the decent thing and it does not speed the other library.

Los Angeles describes a narrow case where staff will move loans and holds, and it is not a general nonresident feature. Their Libby page says an OverDrive instant digital card expires after a year and cannot be renewed at this time. If you have loans on that instant card, you apply for a regular LAPL card or e-card, add it, and email cso@lapl.org with your phone number and the new card number so they can transfer the loans and holds. That is LAPL helping LAPL cardholders move between two LAPL products. It is not a way to move a Houston hold to Plano. Nobody offers that.

Loan length and the automatic return

You choose a loan length inside the range the library allows, if the library allows a choice. Libby's help describes the app. The library decides the maximum. A 21-day loan feels generous until you remember you may only have a handful of slots. Fairfax's 10-item cap means a 21-day loan occupies one of ten seats for three weeks. Returning a book you finished on day two gives the seat back.

There is no late fee on a Libby loan that returns itself. There can be a late fee, or a block, on a physical item if the card you bought also checks out paper. Fresno's non-resident card does check out physical items. If you never visit, you will not have that problem. If you visit and take a book home to another state, you have a due date and a replacement bill. Read the card type. Digital-only cards and full-service cards are different debts.

Why wait times blew up the programs

The libraries that closed or narrowed cards said the digital bill was the reason, in their own words. Houston pointed at funding and then at e-books and audiobooks. New Orleans pointed at demand and the cost of e-books when it shut the online form. Orange County Library System said the fee no longer covered digital materials. Virginia Beach said use-based pricing for Libby, Hoopla, and Kanopy was no longer sustainable if every non-resident cardholder got those apps free.

A long hold line is the public face of that bill. Each extra cardholder is another person who can place a hold on the same expensive license. Libraries are allowed to decide that their taxpayers come first. Some of them charge you to stand in the line. Some of them close the line. Neither choice creates more copies. Only a bigger license budget does that, and a $38 fee from one out-of-state reader does not buy a new license of every bestseller. Broward's $38, Queens's $50, and Cincinnati's $90 are contributions. They are not a concierge copy.

How to use a second card without fooling yourself

Add the card. Search for three titles you actually want, not a random classic that every library owns with no wait. Note which library has an available copy and which has a hold measured in weeks. Borrow the available one. Place a hold with the library that is shorter, and suspend the longer hold if the app lets you, so you are not notified twice and then stuck with two copies of a book you will not finish.

Put the expiration date of the paid card on a calendar. A hold that arrives the week after the card dies is a hold you cannot check out. Renew before that if the library still allows renewal. Houston's readers learned what happens when the renewal disappears and the hold does not.

If both libraries have long waits, a third card will not magically be short. Look at Hoopla for that title if both of your cards include Hoopla and you have not used the monthly cap. Hoopla's model is often no queue and a hard cap, which is the other way to spend the month. Cincinnati's cap is 20. Charlotte's 2020 post said six. Check the number in the app, because caps change, and then stop when you hit it. The cap is the library protecting the same budget the hold line is protecting. You are looking at one problem through two doors.

Magazines are the exception that makes people think the whole app works like a newsstand. Fairfax says e-magazine checkouts are unlimited, while e-books and audiobooks share a cap of 10. A magazine that is always available does not mean the new novel is always available. They are different licenses sitting in the same app. When you test a new card, test it with the kind of title you actually wait for. A free magazine download will tell you the login works. It will not tell you whether you skipped a six-month hold.

Recommend buttons and "notify me" tags are not holds. Libby's help describes notifying you when a library you use buys a title it does not own yet. That is a wish, not a place in line. A second card helps a notify-me only if the second library already owns the book or is more likely to buy it. You cannot see the buying plan. You can see today's copies. Decide from today's copies.

If you are placing holds for a book club that meets on a date, count backward from the meeting by the loan length and then by a pessimistic wait. A 21-day loan that arrives three days before the meeting is a loan you will not finish, and returning it late is not an option because Libby returns it for you. Borrow the copy that is available now, from whichever of your allowed cards has it, and let the hold be the backup. Two cards are a way to raise the odds that one copy is free today. They are not a way to reserve a specific week.

Sources

  1. Libby help, quick start
  2. Fairfax County Public Library Libby guide
  3. Brooklyn Public Library Welcome Card FAQ
  4. Cincinnati and Hamilton County Public Library on e-books
  5. Queens Public Library audiobook instructions