Libby, Hoopla, Kanopy, and cloudLibrary are not the same shelf

Last updated

Each app is a separate contract. A card can include one, exclude another, and never mention the rest. The differences change how you wait and what you pay.

A modern library with white shelves of books arranged in a curve.
Stock photograph of a library or of books. It is not a picture of a specific library in this directory.

People say "the library app" and mean whichever icon is on their phone. The libraries do not mean that. Libby, Hoopla, Kanopy, and cloudLibrary are four vendors. A library signs a contract with each one separately, sets a budget for each one, and can hand a nonresident a card that includes some of them and not others. If you buy a card for the wrong icon, the card can be real and still useless to you.

Libby is the holds app

Libby, by OverDrive, is the app most people are trying to add a second card to. The library licenses a set number of copies of an e-book or audiobook. One copy lends to one person at a time. If all the copies are out, you place a hold and wait. Loans are commonly measured in days and then return themselves. Fairfax County's Libby guide says you may borrow 10 items at a time, magazines are unlimited, and loans can run up to 21 days with no late fee. Brooklyn's Welcome Card FAQ, for New York residents, says up to 20 e-books or audiobooks and up to 10 OverDrive holds, with a default loan of 21 days. Those limits are per library, not a Libby-wide rule.

Libby's help site says you add a card from the Library button, and that you can add another card for a library you already saved. Each card borrows from that library's licenses only. Searching while you have two cards can show you which library owns an available copy. It does not let Queens's copy satisfy a hold you placed at home.

OverDrive is the company. Libby is the app. Older help pages still say OverDrive. Queens's audiobook page mentions both. Broward's FAQ still talks about returning Kindle and Adobe files, which is the older download path, and also tells you to look at OverDrive and Hoopla. When a library says OverDrive in 2026, it almost always means the collection you open in Libby. If a page is explicit that you must use a retired app, follow the page. Otherwise use Libby.

A nonresident card can be shut out of this collection even when the library offers it to residents. Fresno's table is the clean example: non-residents get an X for Libby and a check for cloudLibrary. Paying nothing does not put you in the Libby column.

Hoopla is the cap app

Hoopla lends a different way. Many titles do not have a holds queue. You borrow and the library pays a fee for that borrow. Because the bill rises with use, libraries set caps. The cap is the product, as much as the catalog is.

Cincinnati's help says customers have a checkout limit of 20 Hoopla downloads a month, and that the whole system can also hit a daily lending limit that resets at 8 p.m. Eastern. If you see a message that the daily limit has been met, the library tells you to try later. Charlotte Mecklenburg's May 5, 2020 post said hoopla checkouts were limited to six items a month. That post is old. Caps move. The pattern does not: Hoopla is where a second card changes your month, because each library's cap is separate. A home card at six and a second card at six is twelve, if both cards actually include Hoopla.

Monroe County says Hoopla is not available to out-of-county cardholders. You can pay $25, get Libby, and still have no Hoopla. Virginia Beach put Hoopla in the paid bundle with Libby and Kanopy, and left other digital tools outside the fee. Read the verb. "Not available to this card" and "available if you pay this extra fee" are both Hoopla policies. They are not the same policy.

You need a library card and, at Cincinnati, a PIN, plus a free Hoopla account. The library card does not create the Hoopla login by itself. Libby and Hoopla do not share a shelf. A title you borrowed in one is not in the other.

Kanopy is the film app

Kanopy is a streaming film service some libraries buy. It shows up less often than Libby on card pages, which is why most of our listings say not stated rather than yes or no. Silence is not a no. It is an admission that the page we read did not mention it.

Where a library does mention it, believe the mention. Monroe County groups Kanopy with Hoopla as unavailable to out-of-county cards. Virginia Beach groups Kanopy with Hoopla and Libby as the three services non-residents have to pay for. Those two sentences are enough to stop guessing. If your reason for a second card is a film, and the card page never says Kanopy, do not assume the $50 includes it. Ask, or pick a library that has already named it.

cloudLibrary is the other e-book app

cloudLibrary is another e-book and e-audiobook app. It is not a tab inside Libby. Fresno gives non-residents cloudLibrary and refuses them Libby. That split is the entire argument for reading the table. Someone who downloads Libby, adds a Fresno non-resident card, and cannot sign into the collection has not been scammed. They have used the wrong app for the column they were issued.

If a library does not mention cloudLibrary, we do not mark it yes. Many systems never offered it. A few use it alongside Libby for residents and drop one of them for non-residents. You only know which is which from the page.

Why the contracts get sliced this way

Libraries say the digital bill is the part that grew. Orange County Library System, ending its fee card on July 31, 2026, said the annual fee no longer covered the cost of service, particularly digital materials. Houston, ending out-of-state renewals, said funding and resources, and then said out-of-state cardholders would lose online resources including e-books and audiobooks. New Orleans, ending online non-resident applications, cited unsustainable demand and the cost of e-books. Virginia Beach said it pays for Hoopla, Libby, and Kanopy based on use, and that use had made the old free-for-every-cardholder model unsustainable if residents were to keep the services.

You do not need a national statistic to see the local result. The expensive apps are the ones that get a fence. The fence is sometimes a higher fee, sometimes an in-person rule, sometimes an X in a table, sometimes the end of the program. The physical collection is rarely the thing they are trying to protect from a reader in another state, because a physical book has to be mailed or picked up. The app is the thing that travels.

How to choose an app on purpose

Name the thing you are trying to borrow. A bestseller audiobook with a long wait is a Libby problem, and a second Libby card helps only if that library owns a copy and your card is allowed to borrow it. A movie is a Kanopy or Hoopla question, and only if the card includes that vendor. A comic or a TV episode is often Hoopla, under that library's monthly cap. An e-book from a library that has switched non-residents to cloudLibrary will never appear in Libby, no matter how carefully you type the card number.

Then read one library's page for that vendor's name, next to your card type. Yes, no, or not stated. Pay only on yes, unless you are willing to ask the library to fill in the blank and wait for the answer. The four icons on your home screen are four bills. The card fee is a fifth bill, and it does not automatically settle the other four.

DeKalb County names both Libby and hoopla on the same card page, which is the easy case, and then limits the $50 card to Georgia residents. An app yes and a geographic no can sit on one screen. Read both. The icon is the smaller fact.

A practical way to see the split is to pick one title you already know and search it in each app after the card is added, instead of trusting the icon to mean the catalog. Libby will show a hold or a borrow. Hoopla will show a borrow that spends the monthly cap, or it will show that the card is not allowed, which is what Monroe tells out-of-county readers to expect. Kanopy will show films or it will reject the card. cloudLibrary is a separate install. Fresno's non-resident column is a cloudLibrary card. Installing Libby for that card is how you conclude the library "doesn't work," when the table told you which app does.

Keep the logins separate in a note on your phone: library name, card number, PIN, which apps the page named, and the date the card expires. You will not remember in March which of the four icons belonged to a $38 fee you paid in November. The note is not a backup of the books. It is a backup of the decision. When a library changes the rule, the note is also how you know which page to re-read. Virginia Beach's change was specifically three of the four. A reader who only wrote down "Virginia Beach card" would not know which icons the new fee was buying.

Sources

  1. Libby help, quick start
  2. Fresno County Public Library card table
  3. Monroe County Library System out-of-county page
  4. Virginia Beach Public Library non-resident page
  5. Cincinnati and Hamilton County Public Library Hoopla help
  6. Charlotte Mecklenburg Library on OverDrive and hoopla